- Ex-Dutch football star Johan Neeskens dies
- Man Utd battling to improve fortunes, says Evans
- What is microRNA? Nobel-winning discovery explained
- Masood, Abdullah centuries lift Pakistan to 328-4 in first England Test
- Hurricane Milton strengthens fast, threatens Mexico, Florida
- Tunisia's President Saied set for landslide election win
- Barca hoping to return to Camp Nou 'by end of year'
- Trump to open second golf course at Scotland resort in summer 2025
- Super-sub Jhon Duran rewarded with new Aston Villa deal
- US duo win Nobel for gene regulation breakthrough
- Masood hits first ton for four years to power Pakistan to 233-1
- Fritz wins delayed match to reach Shanghai Masters third round
- Naomi Osaka pulls out of Japan Open with back injury
- Weather may delay launch of mission to study deflected asteroid
- China to flesh out economic stimulus plans after bumper rally
- Artist Marina Abramovic hopes first China show offers tech respite
- Asian markets track Wall St rally on US jobs data
- Pakistan 122-1 at lunch in first England Test
- Kazakhs approve plan for first nuclear power plant
- World marks anniversary of Oct. 7 attack on Israel
- 'Second family': tennis stars hunt winning formula with new coaches
- Philippines, South Korea agree to deepen maritime cooperation
- Mexico mayor murdered days after taking office
- Sardinia's sheep farmers battle bluetongue as climate warms
- Japan govt admits doctoring 'untidy' cabinet photo
- Israel marks first anniversary of Hamas's October 7 attack
- Darvish tames Ohtani as Padres thrash Dodgers
- Asian markets track Wall St rally on jobs data
- Family affair as LeBron, Bronny James make Lakers bow
- Cancer, cardiovascular drugs tipped for Nobel as prize week opens
- As Great Salt Lake dries, Utah Republicans pardon Trump climate skepticism
- Amazon activist warns of 'critical situation' ahead of UN forum
- Mourners pay tribute to latest victims of deadly Channel crossing
- Tunisia incumbent Saied set to win presidential vote: exit polls
- Phillies win thriller to level Mets series
- Yu bags first PGA Tour win with playoff win
- PSG held by Nice to leave Monaco clear at top of Ligue 1
- AC Milan fall at Fiorentina after De Gea's penalty heroics
- Lewandowski treble for leaders Barca as Atletico held
- Fresh Israeli strikes hit south Beirut
- Sucic stunner earns Real Sociedad draw against Atletico
- PSG draw with Nice, fail to reclaim top spot in Ligue 1
- Gudmundsson downs AC Milan after De Gea's penalty heroics for Fiorentina
- 'Yes' vote prevails in Kazakhstan nuclear plant vote: TV
- 'Difficult day': Oct 7 commemorations begin with festival memorial
- Commemorations begin for anniversary of attack on Israel
- Lewandowski hat-trick powers Liga leaders Barca to Alaves victory
- 'Nothing gets in way of team,' says Celtics' MVP hopeful Tatum
- India maintain Pakistan stranglehold as Windies cruise at Women's T20 World Cup
- 'We will win!': Mozambique's ruling party confident at final vote rally
CMSC | -0.02% | 24.695 | $ | |
RBGPF | -1.16% | 60.1 | $ | |
RYCEF | -1.16% | 6.9 | $ | |
RELX | -0.83% | 45.91 | $ | |
VOD | 0% | 9.66 | $ | |
SCS | -1.41% | 12.79 | $ | |
GSK | 0.6% | 39.055 | $ | |
NGG | -0.88% | 65.92 | $ | |
BTI | -0.18% | 35.225 | $ | |
RIO | -0.19% | 69.57 | $ | |
AZN | -0.12% | 77.375 | $ | |
CMSD | -0.13% | 24.78 | $ | |
BCC | -1.29% | 137.125 | $ | |
BCE | -0.14% | 33.662 | $ | |
JRI | -0.16% | 13.259 | $ | |
BP | 0.78% | 33.14 | $ |
'The foxes are guarding the hen house': Russia's war highlights UN impotence
It was arguably the ultimate illustration of UN powerlessness: an emergency Security Council meeting designed to avoid war rendered redundant by Russia's invasion of Ukraine just minutes after the late-night session began.
As UN chief Antonio Guterres and member state after member state on the 15-country council urged Vladimir Putin to step back from the brink, the Russian leader was already sending his troops across the border.
The ambassadors of the United States, Britain, France and others reading pre-prepared speeches calling for Putin to pursue diplomacy seemed unaware of what journalists watching the proceedings already knew: Russia's president was on state television announcing that his military operation had begun.
As news filtered through to the chamber at the UN's headquarters in New York, the mood turned to one of anger, despair and hopelessness.
Adding an air of surrealism was the identity of the country chairing the meeting: Russia, in its role as temporary president of the council.
"I call on every one of you to do everything possible to stop the war," pleaded an emotional Ukrainian ambassador Sergiy Kyslytsya.
But as with the 2003 invasion of Iraq by the United States and Britain, the United Nations again proved incapable of preventing conflict.
With Putin intent on launching his invasion and Russia a permanent council member with the power to veto resolutions, what if anything could the body have done?
"The Security Council was never going to solve this crisis," Richard Gowan, a UN expert at the International Crisis Group think tank, told AFP.
"That is because of Russia's veto power, plus the simple fact that President Putin clearly doesn't give a damn about international opinion or diplomacy."
Since its creation in 1945, the UN has been unable to stop any conflict started by one of its five permanent members: Britain, China, France, Russia and the United States.
The same five powers that emerged victorious from World War II wield all the power today, relegating the organization to a role focused primarily on providing humanitarian aid in natural disasters and wars, in some cases succeeding in limiting the expansion of conflicts.
The format of the Security Council has not changed in 77 years, with other countries rotating through the body's 10 non-permanent member spots, which do not have veto power.
- Deadlocked reform -
Experts and governments have long argued for reform to take into account an international order that is now multipolar, with countries like India, Japan and Germany arguing that they should have a permanent, veto-wielding seat.
But reform efforts have been deadlocked for years, however, hampering the credibility of the council, which has all too often been riven by division and infighting, leading to inaction.
"Essentially the foxes are guarding the hen house. Thus, the Security Council is back to its Cold War paralysis," Pamela Chasek, chair of the political science department at Manhattan College in New York, told AFP.
Russia has not hesitated to wield its veto, doing so more than 15 times with regards to the Syria conflict.
Moscow will exercise its right again on Friday, to block a resolution proposed by Western powers that would "condemn in the strongest terms the Russian invasion of Ukraine," according to a senior UN official.
A similar text will then be sent to the General Assembly, which brings together all 193 members of the UN. Experts will closely watch the vote to see how isolated Russia is, but ultimately it is non-binding.
A similar scenario occurred in 2014 when Russia annexed Crimea. Eight years later, Russia is still in control of that region.
- 'Saddest day' -
At Wednesday night's session, as ambassadors learned of Russia's invasion via their mobile phones, many made second speeches, directing much of their anger at Moscow's envoy Vassily Nebenzia.
"There is no purgatory for war criminals. They go straight to hell, ambassador," Kyslytsya, the Ukrainian representative, told him.
US ambassador Linda Thomas-Greenfield was seen consoling Kyslytsya and afterwards, a dejected Guterres said Russia's military assault marked "the saddest day" of his tenure as UN chief.
For some UN watchers, the invasion is not only a personal failure for Guterres but also further evidence of the declining stature of the world body.
"The mediation efforts by the Secretary-General would have been taken seriously 20 years ago," Trita Parsi of the Quincy Institute think tank told AFP.
"Today, no one even notices his absence because no one has even an expectation that the UN or the Secretary-General will play such a role."
So what can we expect the Security Council to achieve in the Ukraine crisis?
"For now, the UNSC is a theater where the West and Russia can shout at each other," said Gowan.
"It won't do much to bring this war to a close."
prh-ft-mlm-pdh/sst
M.Thompson--AMWN