- 38 dead as Azerbaijani jet crashes in Kazakhstan
- Crisis-hit Valencia hire West Brom's Corberan as new boss
- Suriname ex-dictator and fugitive Desi Bouterse dead at 79
- 35 feared dead as Azerbaijani jet crashes in Kazakhstan
- Pope calls for 'arms to be silenced' in Christmas appeal
- Syria authorities say torched 1 million captagon pills
- Pope calls for 'arms to be silenced' across world
- 32 survivors as Azerbaijani jet crashes in Kazakhstan
- Pakistan air strikes kill 46 in Afghanistan, Kabul says
- Liverpool host Foxes, Arsenal prepare for life without Saka
- Japan FM raises 'serious concerns' over China military buildup
- Pope's sombre message in Christmas under shadow of war
- Zelensky condemns Russian 'inhumane' Christmas attack on energy grid
- Sweeping Vietnam internet law comes into force
- Pope kicks off Christmas under shadow of war
- Catholics hold muted Christmas mass in Indonesia's Sharia stronghold
- Japan's top diplomat in China to address 'challenges'
- Thousands attend Christmas charity dinner in Buenos Aires
- Demand for Japanese content booms post 'Shogun'
- As India's Bollywood shifts, stars and snappers click
- Mystery drones won't interfere with Santa's work: US tracker
- Djokovic eyes more Slam glory as Swiatek returns under doping cloud
- Australia's in-form Head confirmed fit for Boxing Day Test
- Brazilian midfielder Oscar returns to Sao Paulo
- 'Wemby' and 'Ant-Man' to make NBA Christmas debuts
- US agency focused on foreign disinformation shuts down
- On Christmas Eve, Pope Francis launches holy Jubilee year
- 'Like a dream': AFP photographer's return to Syria
- Chiefs seek top seed in holiday test for playoff-bound NFL teams
- Panamanians protest 'public enemy' Trump's canal threat
- Cyclone death toll in Mayotte rises to 39
- Ecuador vice president says Noboa seeking her 'banishment'
- Leicester boss Van Nistelrooy aware of 'bigger picture' as Liverpool await
- Syria authorities say armed groups have agreed to disband
- Maresca expects Man City to be in title hunt as he downplays Chelsea's chancs
- Man Utd boss Amorim vows to stay on course despite Rashford row
- South Africa opt for all-pace attack against Pakistan
- Guardiola adamant Man City slump not all about Haaland
- Global stocks mostly higher in thin pre-Christmas trade
- Bethlehem marks sombre Christmas under shadow of war
- NASA probe makes closest ever pass by the Sun
- 11 killed in blast at Turkey explosives plant
- Indonesia considers parole for ex-terror chiefs: official
- Global stocks mostly rise in thin pre-Christmas trade
- Postecoglou says Spurs 'need to reinforce' in transfer window
- Le Pen says days of new French govt numbered
- Global stocks mostly rise after US tech rally
- Villa boss Emery set for 'very difficult' clash with Newcastle
- Investors swoop in to save German flying taxi startup
- How Finnish youth learn to spot disinformation
'Disturbing' Nord Stream leaks show danger of global methane emissions
Planet-heating methane spewing into the atmosphere from the damaged Nord Stream pipelines only has a modest impact on climate change, say scientists, but sharply highlights the risks of fossil-fuel driven greenhouse gas emissions.
The European Union has said it believes the leaks to the strategically important pipelines, Nord Stream 1 and 2, were caused by a "deliberate act".
While not in operation the pipelines still contained gas, and Danish authorities said they will now likely continue to empty out, with leaks expected to continue for at least a week.
With only rough estimates available as to how much natural gas might bubble up through the Baltic Sea, scientists expressed concerns about climate and environmental impacts -- but stressed that the amounts of methane involved were a tiny fraction of global emissions.
"It is a real travesty, an environmental crime if it was deliberate," said Jeffrey Kargel, senior scientist at the Planetary Research Institute in Arizona, calling the leak "disturbing".
But he added: "Although the amount of gas lost from the pipeline obviously is large, it is not the climate disaster one might think."
What gas is leaking?
Natural gas is composed primarily of methane.
This is about 28 times more powerful than carbon dioxide on a century-long timescale -- although it only lingers in the atmosphere for about a decade, compared to hundreds or thousands of years for C02.
Some of the methane emitted from the pipes will be oxidised in the water into C02, said Grant Allen, professor of Atmospheric Physics at the University of Manchester.
"But given how violent the venting of natural gas appears to be, most of the gas will reach the sea surface as methane," he said.
Methane is responsible for roughly 30 percent of the global rise in temperatures to date, even though it is far less abundant in the atmosphere than CO2.
How big is the leak?
This is the subject of much uncertainty, although some experts and organisations have attempted to calculate the potential amount of gas in the pipelines.
One estimate is that there was up to 177 million cubic metres of natural gas still in Nord Stream 2, said Allen.
"This is not a small amount of gas, and represents a reckless emission of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere," he said, adding it was equivalent to the natural gas used by 124,000 UK homes in a year.
Greenpeace have used similar figures to roughly estimate that the leak emissions could be equivalent to eight months of Denmark's total greenhouse gas emissions.
Paul Balcombe, an honorary lecturer at the Department of Chemical Engineering at Imperial College London, said estimates for the gas in the pipes range from around 150 to 300 million cubic metres.
"It is unlikely that they will release all their contents," he told the Science Media Centre.
But he added if just one of the pipes did completely empty out it would be about twice as much as the worst methane leak recorded in the United States, the 2015 Aliso Canyon leak.
"It would have a very large environmental and climate impact indeed, even if it released a fraction of this," he said.
Lauri Myllyvirta from the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air said he has calculated an estimated potential leak of between 180 and 270 kilotons from the two pipelines.
This figure is significant but, he said, is probably only 1.5 percent of the total annual methane emissions from oil and gas operations in Russia.
The International Energy Agency estimates this was some 18 million tonnes in 2021.
How does it compare to global emissions?
The IEA has decried the enormous amount of methane that leaks from fossil fuel operations every year -- estimating the amount lost last year globally was broadly similar to all the gas used in Europe's power sector.
The leak will certainly have a "strong immediate warming effect and cause poor air quality" Piers Forster, director of the Priestley International Centre for Climate at the University of Leeds.
But ultimately its effect is small compared to the daily leaks from the world’s poorly-maintained gas networks, which see around 10 percent of global gas supply lost.
Experts said the incident further underscores the need to urgently switch from polluting fossil fuels, both to combat climate change and ensure energy security.
This year's energy crisis caused by Russia's invasion of Ukraine has already "supercharged the clean energy transition", Myllyvirta said.
Kargel, who calculated that the Nord Stream leak was roughly equivalent to 2.5 hours of global emissions, said it was a reminder of the urgent need to slash greenhouse emissions.
"The global climate is changing drastically, with huge impacts on extreme climate mounting every year, decade after decade," he said.
A.Jones--AMWN