- Shanghai stocks soar to extend stimulus rally amid Asia-wide drop
- Australia moves to expand Antarctic marine park
- Tragedy of Madrid street sweeper highlights how heatwaves kill
- Survivors wait for aid as Trump's lies help cloud Helene response
- Fleeing Israeli bombs, Lebanon's displaced met with suspicion
- Jila Mossaed, from refugee poet to Swedish Academy
- Will Tesla's robotaxi reveal live up to hype?
- Drugs, people smuggling at heart of Mexico's raging violence
- 'Invisibility' and quantum computing tipped for physics Nobel
- Musk says he is 'all in' on Trump in US election
- Category 5 Hurricane Milton roars towards storm-battered Florida
- Carpenter bomb stuns Guardians as Tigers level series
- Harris, Trump and Biden mark Oct. 7 attacks as US election looms
- Oil prices extend gains on Mideast tensions, Wall Street falls
- US judge orders Google to open Android to rival app stores
- On attacks anniversary, Israel fights 'sacred' multi-front war
- Nobel scientist uncovered tiny genetic switches with big potential
- Grammy-winning Cissy Houston, mother of Whitney, dies at 91
- UN biodiversity summit in Colombia aims to turn words into action
- Georgia Supreme Court reinstates six-week abortion ban
- 'Dark day': Victims mourned around the globe on Oct. 7 anniversary
- On attacks anniversary, Israel fights multi-front war
- Mexican mayor murdered days after taking office
- Intensifying to Category 5, Hurricane Milton targets Florida
- Mission to probe smashed asteroid launches despite hurricane
- Biden, Harris mark Oct. 7 with call for Mideast peace
- Dupont set for Toulouse return after post-Olympic holiday
- French rugby bosses tighten discipline after nightmare Argentina tour
- Oil prices extend gains on Mideast tensions, Wall Street slips
- Visitors to get rare view of Rome's Trevi Fountain
- Europe's asteroid mission Hera launches despite hurricane
- Man City and Premier League both claim victory in legal case
- Deschamps delight as 'light back on' for Pogba after doping ban
- Biden, Harris urge Mideast peace on Oct. 7 anniversary
- Neeskens, tough midfielder in Cruyff's Ajax and Dutch teams
- UN warns world's water cycle becoming ever more erratic
- Oil prices extend gains on Mideast tensions, Wall Street retreats
- Ex-Dutch football star Johan Neeskens dies
- Man Utd battling to improve fortunes, says Evans
- What is microRNA? Nobel-winning discovery explained
- Masood, Abdullah centuries lift Pakistan to 328-4 in first England Test
- Hurricane Milton strengthens fast, threatens Mexico, Florida
- Tunisia's President Saied set for landslide election win
- Barca hoping to return to Camp Nou 'by end of year'
- Trump to open second golf course at Scotland resort in summer 2025
- Super-sub Jhon Duran rewarded with new Aston Villa deal
- US duo win Nobel for gene regulation breakthrough
- Masood hits first ton for four years to power Pakistan to 233-1
- Fritz wins delayed match to reach Shanghai Masters third round
- Naomi Osaka pulls out of Japan Open with back injury
RBGPF | -1.97% | 58.94 | $ | |
SCS | -0.15% | 12.95 | $ | |
BCC | 1.68% | 141.27 | $ | |
NGG | -1.56% | 65.48 | $ | |
RELX | -0.54% | 46.04 | $ | |
AZN | -0.78% | 76.87 | $ | |
CMSC | -0.53% | 24.57 | $ | |
RIO | -0.11% | 69.62 | $ | |
GSK | -0.49% | 38.63 | $ | |
BTI | -0.26% | 35.2 | $ | |
BP | 0.78% | 33.14 | $ | |
JRI | -0.76% | 13.18 | $ | |
BCE | -0.54% | 33.53 | $ | |
RYCEF | -1.45% | 6.88 | $ | |
VOD | 0.31% | 9.69 | $ | |
CMSD | -0.09% | 24.79 | $ |
Spain's amnesty for separatists bogged down in legal wrangles
Three weeks after it was approved by Spain's parliament, an amnesty law for Catalan separatists involved in a botched 2017 secession bid is entangled in legal wrangling and has yet to benefit anyone.
Judges have two months since the final approval of the bill on May 30 to apply the law, which is expected to affect around 400 people including the former head of the regional government of Catalonia, Carles Puigdemont.
The aim was for arrest warrants and criminal charges filed against separatists to be annulled, even while appeals against the amnesty law are heard by higher courts -- a process that could take years.
But the courts must decide to apply the amnesty on a case-by-case basis, a laborious process that takes time.
"Political leaders and MPs are the masters of creating legislation but jurists are the masters of applying the law," Alfons Lopez Tena, a jurist and former pro-independence lawmaker in Catalonia's regional parliament, wrote in a recent article published in legal news website Confilegal.
If a judge "considers that the law, or one of its articles, violates European legislation, he can independently decide not to apply it, without the need for an appeal or a preliminary question", he added.
Socialist Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez, who had opposed the law in the past, agreed to grant the amnesty in exchange for obtaining support from Catalan separatist parties in parliament.
That support was essential for him to win reappointment for another four-year term in office after an inconclusive general election in July 2023.
- Political crisis -
The most high-profile beneficiary of the amnesty is expected to be Puigdemont who fled Spain shortly after the independence bid and now divides his time between Belgium and France.
While Puigdemont was Catalan regional leader, his administration pressed ahead with a referendum on independence on October 1, 2017, despite a ban by the Spanish courts.
Several weeks later, the Catalan parliament made a symbolic declaration of independence, prompting the central government to impose direct rule on the region.
The events triggered Spain's biggest political crisis since the advent of democracy following the 1975 death of dictator Francisco Franco.
Puigdemont had said he hoped to return to Spain soon but there is still a warrant for his arrest and a Spanish court is still investigating him for the alleged crimes of embezzlement and disobedience related to the secession bid.
He is also still under investigation for the alleged crime of terrorism over protests in 2019 against the jailing of several separatist leaders involved in the referendum that sometimes turned violent.
Judges have decided that arrest warrants will remain in force pending the resolution of any doubts about the legality of the amnesty law by higher courts.
- 'Legal adventures' -
There is also a lack of consensus over if the amnesty covers embezzlement -- one of the main offences linked to the secession bid.
The issue is one of interpretation. The law allows the amnesty to be applied if the funds were used to finance the pro-independence process, but not if the money was taken for personal gain.
Spain's chief prosecutor, Alvaro Garcia Ortiz, argues the amnesty applies to all crimes including embezzlement but the four prosecutors handling Puigdemont's case disagree.
The prosecutor's office decided on Tuesday with 19 votes in favour and 17 against to back Garcia Ortiz's position.
But judges will have the last word as the amnesty law specifies that they will decide "its application to each specific case".
Catalan separatists consider the delays in applying the amnesty unjustified and are growing impatient.
Puigdemont's lawyer, Gonzalo Boyle, has sent a letter to the Court of Auditors -- the body charged with verifying public spending -- to ask that it annul "without further delay or legal adventures" the process against Puigdemont regarding the money the regional Catalan government allegedly used in the secession bid.
A.Malone--AMWN