- X says 'alert' to manipulation efforts after pro-Russia bots report
- US, European markets rise before Boeing unveils sweeping job cuts
- Small Quebec company dominates one part of NHL hockey: jerseys
- Comoros shock Tunisia, Salah, Mbeumo strike in AFCON qualifiers
- Boeing to cut 10% of workforce as it sees big Q3 loss
- Germany win in Nations League as 10-man Dutch rescue point
- Undav brace sends Germany to victory against Bosnia
- Israel says fired at 'threat' near UN position in Lebanon
- Want to film in Paris? No sexism allowed
- Ecuador's last mountain iceman dies at 80
- Milton leaves at least 16 dead, millions without power in Florida
- Senegal set to announce breakaway development agenda: PM
- UN says 2 peacekeepers wounded in south Lebanon explosions
- Injury-hit Australia thrash 'embarrassing' Pakistan at Women's T20 World Cup
- Internal TikTok documents show prioritization of traffic over well-being
- Israel says fired at 'immediate threat' near UN position in Lebanon
- New US coach Pochettino hails Pulisic but worries over workload
- Brazil orders closure of 2,000 betting sites
- UK govt urged to raise pro-democracy tycoon's case with China
- Sculptor Lalanne's animal creations sell for $59 mn
- From Tesla to Trump: Behind Musk's giant leap into politics
- US, European markets rise as investors weigh rates, earnings
- In Colombia, children trade plastic waste for school supplies
- Supercharged hurricanes trigger 'perfect storm' for disinformation
- JPMorgan Chase profits top estimates, bank sees 'resilient' US economy
- Djokovic proves staying power as he progresses to Shanghai semi-finals
- Sheffield Utd boss Wilder 'numb' after Baldock death
- Little progress at key meet ahead of COP29 climate summit
- Fans immerse themselves in Marina Abramovic's first China exhibition
- Israel says conducting review after UN peacekeepers wounded in Lebanon
- 'Party atmosphere': Skygazers treated to another aurora show
- Djokovic 'overwhelmed' after 'greatest rival' Nadal's retirement
- Zelensky in Berlin says hopes war with Russia will end next year
- Kyrgyzstan opens rare probe into glacier destruction
- European Mediterranean states discuss Middle East, migration
- Djokovic proves staying power as progresses to Shanghai semi-finals
- Hurricane Milton leaves at least 16 dead as Florida cleans up
- Britain face 'ultimate challenge' in America's Cup duel with New Zealand
- Lebanon calls for 'immediate' ceasefire in Israel-Hezbollah war
- Nihon Hidankyo: Japan's A-bomb survivors awarded Nobel
- Thunberg leads pro-Palestinian, climate protest in Milan
- Boat captain rescued clinging to cooler in Gulf of Mexico after storm Milton
- Tears, warnings after Japan atomic survivors group win Nobel
- 'Unspeakable horror': the attacks on Hiroshima and Nagasaki
- Stock markets diverge before China weekend briefing
- Christian villagers 'trapped' in south Lebanon crossfire
- Sabalenka sets up Gauff showdown in Wuhan semis
- EU questions shopping app Temu over illegal products risk
- Kim Sei-young holds lead with late birdies at LPGA Shanghai
- Toulouse welcome Dupont 'boost' as Olympic star returns to Top 14
German court blows 60-bn-euro hole in budget with debt ruling
Germany's top court wiped 60 billion euros from a climate fund Wednesday as it decided the government had broken crucial debt rules, leaving the ruling coalition's budget in disarray and testing its unity anew.
The Federal Constitutional Court had been examining accusations from the main opposition CDU party that Chancellor Olaf Scholz's three-party coalition had acted in contravention of the "debt brake".
This key commitment to balanced budgets caps new borrowing in Europe's top economy to 0.35 percent of gross domestic product.
In particular, it looked at a decision to transfer 60 billion euros ($65 billion) of loan authorisations that had been part of coronavirus pandemic support programmes to a fund aimed mainly at fighting climate change.
The coalition had argued this should be kept outside the main budget, as it was approved as part of emergency funding when the debt brake was suspended during the pandemic.
But the court in Karlsruhe, southwest Germany, found this move was "incompatible" with the constitutionally enshrined debt rules and overturned it, ruling in favour of a legal complaint lodged by the CDU.
"The court's decision means that the volume of the 'climate and transformation fund' is reduced by 60 billion euros," it said in a statement.
If the state "has entered into obligations that it can no longer service as a result of this reduction," it must be compensated for "through other means".
Scholz said the judgement would be "carefully examined", and it could have implications for spending at the national and state levels.
Finance Minister Christian Linder immediately froze the current business plan for the climate fund -- worth about 212 billion euros before the ruling -- affecting projects from 2024 onwards.
- 'Core disagreements' -
The fund is aimed in large part at speeding up Germany's shift to an emissions-free economy.
Funds were also earmarked for other measures, however, such as boosting domestic semiconductor production as Europe seeks to reduce reliance on imports from Asia.
"The government will now have to fill a hole of 60 billion euros," said ING economist Carsten Brzeski, adding it was "bad news" that meant agreement on the 2024 budget could be delayed.
The decision will also likely further strain ties within the coalition, particularly between Scholz's SPD and the Green party on one side, and the pro-market FDP on the other.
The ruling "goes to core disagreements between the coalition partners," analyst Salomon Fiedler of Berenberg Bank told AFP.
"The Greens and large parts of the SPD favour higher deficits and have spoken out against the debt brake in its current form. In contrast, the FDP insists on the debt brake."
The brake was suspended from 2020-2022 to deal with shocks from the coronavirus pandemic and energy crisis, as is permitted during emergencies, but came back into force this year.
In court hearings in June, the government had argued the climate fund also addressed the consequences of the pandemic, which continued to weigh on the economy.
But in their ruling, the judges said "the programmes financed by the (fund) cannot be deemed suitable for crisis management purposes".
It laid out three main requirements for such a budget manoeuvre to meet constitutional rules, and which the coalition had not stuck to.
There needs to be a clear link between an emergency and spending measures, to permit an exemption to the debt brake.
Budgets have to be annual -- the government cannot roll over debt authorisations granted in one year to later years.
And parliament needs to vote on budget laws before the end of the year to which it applies.
D.Kaufman--AMWN